profile

Kyle Jordan

What to do when your copy flops

Published 23 days ago • 2 min read

Hey Reader,

A couple of weeks ago, I wrote an email for a client that I thought was pretty banger.

Like I do with all my projects, I put my ass into it. Meaning, this wasn’t some 15-minute smash the keys and cash-out job. In general, that ain’t my style. I am more of a slow and steady, think about it, rewrite it, edit it, edit it some more, tweak a few more words, then finish it off type of writer.

Anyway… I was pretty pleased with how this effort turned out.

I thought I finally had my audience right where I needed them to send this message.

So, I figured I had a hit on my hands.

Turns out, not so much.

All my hard work delivered ONE single sale. Yuk!

So what was the problem?

Did I send the message at a bad time? Nope. No such thing as a bad time for a good sales message.

Was the copy weak? I don’t think so. (But I’ll let you be the judge.)

The problem was something that trips up marketers and copywriters more often than they’ll admit.

Failing to adhere to Eugene Shawartz’s famous 5th Rule of Marketing:

“You cannot create demand. You can only channel demand.”

In this instance, I was trying to sell my audience on a feature that they don’t, at this time, desire.

Is it a good feature? Yes.

Speaking from personal experience, it's an incredibly valuable feature.

But right now the audience’s desire is 100% focused on other attributes of this product.

Does that mean sending this message was a mistake?

Was all my hard work a big waste of my time and the client’s money?

No. I don’t think so.

The message was worth testing.

Truth is, most sales messaging fails to channel mass desire.

By and large, the 80/20 rule holds true in copywriting just like it does everywhere else.

80% of the sales will come from 20% of your emails, or ads, or social content.

And when you drill down even further, you’re likely to discover that the “20%” of your top-money content all focuses on a similar sales hook.

So, what should you do when your message flops?

First, shake it off. You're gonna fail more than you succeed.

It’s okay to feel a little bad about your losses.

But don’t let it get you down. Instead, use your frustration as fuel for your fire.

Second, if you know the copy is good, figure out why it flopped.

Did you have a bad offer, a dead list, or bad strategy?

All those things can kill good copy.

I’ve seen it.

I have published copy that’s delivered an outpouring of elated responses…

… accompanied by a conversion rate so low you need a microscope to see the sales numbers.

It happens.

But that doesn’t mean the copy sucks.

It just means something you tried didn’t work.

It could even be… and this has happened to me too… you resend the same message that flopped months to years later when the market is in a different mood.. and the copy will crush.

Learning from your failure is the fastest path to your next success.

Or, as my favorite comedian likes to put it:

“The road to a W is littered with a lot of losses.”

Until next time…

Rock on,

Kyle Jordan
The Full Funnel Copywriter

Kyle Jordan

The Full Funnel Copywriter

Subscribe to the ONLY newsletter that pulls the pants down on the World's BEST marketing funnels and shows you why they are so impressive!

Read more from Kyle Jordan

Hey Reader Season one, episode one of the hit TV show Mad Men, opens on a hero in crisis. Don Draper must devise a new ad campaign for Lucky Strike cigarettes. But he’s stuck. He’s been pondering the campaign for days, and he’s got nothing. Then, just as his client’s about to walk away from the table, infuriated that their high-priced ad agency is out of ideas… .. inspiration strikes. And Draper saves the day with a groundbreaking idea for a new campaign. But Mad Men isn’t real. It’s a...

about 1 month ago • 1 min read

Hey Reader I’ve got some good stuff, different stuff, weird stuff, coming your way in the weeks that follow this one. But today, I’ve got to get something off my chest. I’ve spent more time than usual turning down work lately. Not because I don’t want to work. But because, from my perspective, “copywriters” are ruining copywriting. Allow me to clarify that last statement. You see, when I took my first copywriting gig, I had zero experience. I didn’t even know WTF a landing page was. I was...

about 1 month ago • 4 min read

Hey Reader, For any direct-response copywriter who’s been around longer than COVID-19… The long-form sales page was a right of passage. 5000 words (and untold numbers of drafts) of meticulously crafted, avatar-targeted sales copy that's supposed to make the audience scream, “Where’s my wallet? I can’t buy this fast enough!” When I first entered this business, the long-form sales page was the true test of the copywriter’s mettle. Could you run the gauntlet from overpowering headline to...

2 months ago • 4 min read
Share this post